Read from each vendor's own pricing page, on the date shown, with the link. We have not used, tested or bought any of these products.
What dunning software costs in 2026
Dunning is the industry word for chasing a payment that failed and a customer who still means to pay. Every option in this market charges one of three ways: a flat monthly fee, a share of what gets recovered, or nothing at all by leaving Stripe's own retries to handle it. Below is what each one publishes, taken from their own page on the date shown.
The table
Every price below was read from the page linked in the same row on 2 October 2026. Nothing on this page is a quote for your business, an estimate of what a vendor would charge you, or a review of how well any of them works.
| Vendor | What it costs | What that buys | Notes, and where we read it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe — Billing revenue recovery, including Smart Retries | What it costsNo separate charge for the recovery features. Smart Retries, automatic reminders and recovery automations are listed on Stripe's Billing pricing page as features included in Stripe Billing, not sold as their own line item. Stripe Billing itself is charged separately — Stripe lists 0.7% of Billing volume on pay-as-you-go, or one of its monthly tiers. | What that buysUp to 8 retries within 2 weeks by Stripe's recommended default, Stripe's own recovery emails if you switch them on, and recovery analytics. | Notes, and where we read it
Source: stripe.com/billing/pricing — read 2 October 2026 Source: docs.stripe.com/billing/revenue-recovery/smart-retries — read 2 October 2026 |
| Churnkey | What it costs$250 per month, billed yearly, on the Starter plan. | What that buysCancel Flows and Payment Recovery, after a 14-day trial, for teams with less than $5k a month of churn volume. | Notes, and where we read it
Source: churnkey.co/pricing — read 2 October 2026 |
| Churn Buster | What it costs$269 a month starting price for Dunning alone or Cancel Flows alone; $430 a month for both. | What that buysA flat fee set by your MRR tier, with no share of what is recovered. | Notes, and where we read it
Source: churnbuster.io/pricing — read 2 October 2026 |
| Baremetrics Recover | What it costs$129 a month, sold as an add-on to a Baremetrics plan. The cheapest plan on the same page is listed at $75 a month, so the entry cost is a plan plus $129. | What that buysPayment Recovery: automated reminders, customizable card forms, in-app banners and paywalls, and one-click recovery links — their page's words, not ours. | Notes, and where we read it
Source: baremetrics.com/pricing — read 2 October 2026 Source: baremetrics.com/features/recover — read 2 October 2026 |
| Butter Payments | What it costsNo published price. Their pricing page is a form, and the figure is set per deal. | What that buysA revenue share, in their words: “a small percentage of the revenue associated with each invoice recovered through the Butter platform.” | Notes, and where we read it
Source: butterpayments.com/pricing — read 2 October 2026 |
| Paddle | What it costs5% + 50¢ per Checkout transaction. No monthly fee. | What that buysPaddle's checkout with payments, billing and tax compliance bundled in — they operate as merchant of record, and their page describes the rate as all-inclusive: “no added costs, no hidden fees.” | Notes, and where we read it
Source: paddle.com/pricing — read 2 October 2026 |
| RecoverlyThat's us | What it costs20% of recovered revenue for the first 12 months — our target, agreed in writing with each design partner. No setup fee, no monthly fee, no minimum. | What that buysA retry schedule and a message sequence run over the failed invoices on your Stripe account, with the invoice-by-invoice list behind every fee. | Notes, and where we read it
This row is our own offer. The full method behind the fee is on the attribution page linked below. |
| Doing nothing | What it costs$0. | What that buysStripe's own retries, plus whatever nobody notices. | Notes, and where we read it
No vendor page to cite: this row is the absence of one. |
All figures re-read from source on 2026-10-02. The full audit trail — figure by figure, page by page — is at the bottom of this page.
Three things the table can't tell you
1. A flat fee is paid whether or not anything comes back; a share is paid only when it does
That is the entire difference between the two models, and both are defensible. Churn Buster's argument against share-based pricing — that performance is easy to game with flattering reporting — is a real argument, and the only honest answer to it is not a reassurance but a method you can audit. That method is written out in full on the attribution page, with the rule and the invoice list you check it against. We are not claiming a flat fee is a bad deal: plenty of merchants want a bill they can budget for, and Churn Buster's own page argues they break even at roughly a 1% improvement in recovery.
2. Not every published number is the number you would pay
Three of these are starting prices tied to MRR or volume tiers, and one vendor publishes nothing at all. We are not going to estimate what any of them would charge your business — ask them. Notice also which vendors let you price it yourself in about a minute and which ask you to talk to sales first; that is information about who they sell to.
3. Paddle's row is not the same kind of number
It is a merchant-of-record fee — payment processing, tax and checkout — with the retention features bundled in. It is only a comparison if your billing already runs on Paddle, and even then the recovery part is invisible in the price.
How we attribute recovered revenue → is that method, in full, with the invoice list a client checks it against.
The cheapest option is doing nothing — and that is sometimes the right answer
$0, no vendor, no new bill. If your failed payments are mostly temporary — a card short of funds on the day of charging — Stripe's retries already recover much of that on their own, and you may not need anyone at all. A leak audit will say so if that is your situation.
The reason a business does nothing, though, is almost never the price. It is that nobody is assigned to the leak. Failed payments are not a line on anyone's to-do list, the invoice quietly goes past due, and the number sits in a dashboard that no one owns. That is the failure mode a comparison table hides: buying a tool you don't operate adds a bill, not a recovery — and that includes ours.
Which of your failed invoices are recoverable at all is the question no table can answer, because it depends on your invoices. That is what the free Failed-Payment Leak Audit is for: it reads your open failed invoices off a read-only Stripe key and comes back with one page — the money still outstanding, which declines a new card would fix, and which ones nothing would.
What this page does not claim
- We have no customers and we have recovered $0. Our row is a target agreed in writing before anything goes live, not a rate we have billed anyone.
- We haven't used, tested or bought any product on this page. Nothing here is a review, a rating or an endorsement. Every figure is quoted from the vendor's own page and dated.
- Where a vendor doesn't publish a price, we say so rather than estimating it. We have not guessed a number to make the table look complete.
- Prices change and pricing pages get redesigned. If something here no longer matches the vendor's page, their page is right — email us and we'll correct it, and we will re-check these figures and change the date on this page when we do.
- There is no affiliate, referral or sponsorship relationship between Recoverly and any product listed. If one ever exists, it will be disclosed on this page before it is used.
- We are not claiming these tools are bad, or that we are cheaper. A flat fee can be the better choice for a business that wants a predictable bill, and we cannot yet show you a single recovery of our own.
- This page is a price comparison, not a performance comparison. We have deliberately left out every competitor's own results claim — including ones that would flatter the case for paying someone to chase failed payments — because reproducing another company's marketing as if it were evidence is not something a buyer should have to untangle.
Sources — figure by figure
Every figure in the table above, with the page it came from and the date it was read. If one of these no longer matches the vendor's page, the vendor's page is right and this one is out of date.
| Figure or claim quoted above | Source | Read on |
|---|---|---|
| Figure or claim quoted aboveRecovery features are included in Stripe Billing, not a line item; 0.7% of Billing volume pay-as-you-go | Sourcestripe.com/billing/pricing | Read on2026-10-02 |
| Figure or claim quoted above8 tries within 2 weeks recommended default; the hard-decline quote and “attempt_count continues to increment” | Sourcedocs.stripe.com/billing/revenue-recovery/smart-retries | Read on2026-10-02 |
| Figure or claim quoted aboveStarter $250/month billed yearly, under $5k/mo churn volume, includes Cancel Flows and Payment Recovery; Core and Intelligence quote-only for $10k+ monthly churn | Sourcechurnkey.co/pricing | Read on2026-10-02 |
| Figure or claim quoted above$269/mo one product, $430/mo both, ~0.1% of MRR scaling, $2,500 advisory, the pay-for-performance FAQ answer, the 1%-break-even line | Sourcechurnbuster.io/pricing | Read on2026-10-02 |
| Figure or claim quoted abovePayment Recovery +$129/mo as an add-on; plan list $75/$255/$1,152 and FAQ text $49/$189/$749 on the same page; the free-month guarantee | Sourcebaremetrics.com/pricing | Read on2026-10-02 |
| Figure or claim quoted aboveRecover's feature list: automated reminders, card forms, in-app banners and paywalls, one-click recovery links | Sourcebaremetrics.com/features/recover | Read on2026-10-02 |
| Figure or claim quoted aboveRevenue share with the percentage set through a payment health analysis; no figure published; estimator starts at $10M annual revenue | Sourcebutterpayments.com/pricing | Read on2026-10-02 |
| Figure or claim quoted above5% + 50¢ per Checkout transaction, no monthly fee, all-inclusive merchant-of-record pricing | Sourcepaddle.com/pricing | Read on2026-10-02 |
Find out what your own leak is worth
No table can tell you which of your failed invoices are recoverable, because it depends on your invoices. The free Failed-Payment Leak Audit reads your open failed invoices off a read-only Stripe key and comes back with one page: the money still outstanding, which declines a new card would fix, and which ones nothing would.